Atlas vs Faire and wholesale marketplaces

Faire makes the first wholesale order easy. It also takes a share of every order after it. Here is the arithmetic.

The short answer

Find the retailers yourself, then use Faire Direct if your buyers like the terms. Faire charges 0% on retailers you bring to it — and 25% on the ones it brings you.

Faire & wholesale marketplacesAtlas
What you pay25% of a new retailer’s first order, then 15% of every reorder from a retailer the marketplace brought you.1A fixed monthly fee, agreed on the call.
Retailers you bring yourself0% commission through Faire Direct.1Atlas finds them. You can still sell through Faire Direct at 0% if your buyers want Faire’s terms.
Who you reachRetailers browsing Faire, next to every other brand in your category.The retailers, studios and dealers you choose, by name — including the ones who never open Faire.
Payment termsEligible retailers buy now and pay in 60 days; Faire pays you.1Your terms, or Faire Direct’s.
What you keepOrders, but the discovery is Faire’s: stop paying and the stream of new retailers stops.You do. Every domain, inbox, list, sequence and CRM record is registered to you.

What 15% does to a trade account

A new retailer places a $5,000 opening order through the marketplace: Faire keeps $1,250. They reorder four times that year at $5,000: Faire keeps another $3,000. One good account, $4,250 in commission in year one — and the 15% continues on every reorder after that.1 Wholesale usually sits around half your retail price. A quarter, then a sixth, of that half is the difference between a channel and a favour.

When Faire is the right call

When you sell small-ticket goods to a long tail of boutiques. When net-60 terms are what gets a hesitant shop to say yes. When you want wholesale with no admin at all. Faire is very good at that, and for a candle brand the commission can be worth it.

When Atlas is

When your buyers are not boutiques browsing an app: furniture retailers, interior studios, dealers, resorts, hotel groups, gyms. When your order values make 15–25% a five-figure line. When you want to choose the accounts instead of waiting to be found. A furniture brand opened 32 retailers and $480,000 in wholesale POs in 90 days on direct outbound.

Keep what works

Nothing stops you using both. Atlas puts you in front of the retailer; if they want Faire’s payment terms, invite them through Faire Direct and pay 0%.1 You keep the terms and the margin.

See what it would look like for your brand.

We install the complete channel — infrastructure, lists, copy, reply handling — inside your own accounts. 30+ qualified B2B sales calls within 30 days of launch, or we keep working for free.

Book a call
← All comparisons